Mad Anthony’s Pizza

Perfecting the Classics

 - One Slice at a Time.

A person is holding a slice of pizza in front of a neon sign that says 'THE' and has an abstract green outline.

dedicated to crafting high-quality, flavorful pizzas with a classic-modern approach.

Our menu blends tradition with creativity, offering everything from timeless favorites to bold, unique combinations. With a sleek yet inviting atmosphere, Mad Anthony’s is all about delivering an unforgettable pizza experience—one slice at a time.

Signage for Mad Anthony's Pizza with a menu listing various pizza options and prices, positioned inside a restaurant with a window and a counter area.
Close-up of a cheese pizza with pepperoni slices and melted cheese.

At Mad Antony’s, we believe great pizza starts with the freshest ingredients.

From our in house sauce and fresh dough made daily, we strive to create the greatest and continue to learn as we grow. We’re committed to quality at every step, because fresh ingredients make better pizza.

  • I’m devouring entire pizzas on the reg. I might have to buy new pants soon. My doctor asked why my bloodwork came back as 25% homemade garlic sauce. I told him to mind his business.

    Justin Roth

    Taken from google review

  • If I’m not in New York, I almost never bother with anyone’s “New York Style” pizza or this or that; but this is even better than some of the best slices there! I’m beyond obsessed!

    Anna Pheil

    Taken from google review

  • This is our favorite pizza in Cincinnati!

    Trey Vater

    Taken from google review

  • Mad Anthony's is the best pizza in Cincy/NKY - and IMO it's really not that close.

    Ben racke

    Taken from google review